By Anita Samuel
“Flexible deadlines” sound great, right? Isn’t that a part of Universal Design for Learning (UDL)? They give students control, reduce stress, and recognize that life doesn’t stop for school. But here’s the catch—sometimes, what feels flexible to us as instructors isn’t actually fair to everyone.
Stay with me on this, and let’s unpack that.
Flexibility is often seen as a key part of making courses accessible to all our learners. We tell students, “Work at your own pace!” or “Submit anytime this week!” The idea is to make learning more accessible. But in practice, that flexibility can create uneven experiences—and even new barriers.
The Hidden Pressure of Open Deadlines
When there’s no clear structure, some students thrive. But others flounder. Students juggling jobs, caregiving, or time zone differences might want to stay on top of things but struggle without external checkpoints. The result? Deadlines sneak up, motivation slips, and the course quietly leaves some learners behind, desperately trying to catch up.
Group Work Gets Messy
In “work-at-your-own-pace” courses, group projects can become a logistical nightmare. One student finishes early; another plans to start on the last day. No one’s wrong—but it’s chaos. What looked like flexibility turns into confusion and frustration.
Consistency Builds Belonging
Deadlines aren’t just about due dates. They help create rhythm and community. When everyone’s roughly moving together, students see each other’s progress, share ideas, and feel part of a collective learning experience. Flexibility should support that, not dismantle it.
So How Do We Get It Right?
Instead
of thinking of flexibility as no structure, we can think of it as a structured
choice.
Here are a few ideas:
- Use soft deadlines. Have “suggested due dates” that keep the course moving, but still allow for grace when life happens.
- Build in checkpoints. Even in self-paced courses, include weekly reflections or discussion posts to keep connection alive.
- Be transparent. Explain why some dates are firm and others are flexible. Students appreciate clarity more than complete freedom.
- Ask for feedback. What feels supportive to one group might feel overwhelming to another. Let students tell you what works.
True flexibility isn’t about removing structure. It’s about designing it thoughtfully, so students can succeed without feeling lost.
Because flexibility without fairness isn’t really flexibility at all.




